Murder Mystery Stories

Looking for a fun and exciting game for your next get-together? Whether you’re hosting a small family dinner or a bigger birthday/New Year’s party, you’ll find the perfect mystery here. Each game is packed with surprises, secrets, and plenty of twists to keep everyone on their toes. Take a look through our collection, pick the one that suits your group, and get ready for a night of unforgettable fun!

Find the Perfect Murder Mystery for Your Group

Please use the graphic below to easily determine which game is ideal for your group size and gender combination. All murder mysteries are designed such that the host can join as one of the characters as well.

() - coming in 2025

Overview of My Murder Mystery Games

⛰ Peril in the Peaks (4 Players) [2024] ~ 3h

The Rocky Mountains, known for their breathtaking nature and panorama, offer the perfect destination for an adventurous expedition. Five friends, reunited after years apart, decide to set out on this excursion, hoping to revive old bonds and escape the pressures of their busy lives. As they gather around the campfire, surrounded by towering pines and the haunting echoes of distant wildlife, old tensions rise and long-buried secrets begin to surface. Little do they know, this trip will turn into a deadly fight for survival.
Mark your calendars for December 22nd

🏭 Hargrove Mansion (5 Players) [2024, co-written with Bethany Grace] ~3-4h

Tonight, you will step into the shoes of the Hargrove family and their close associates as we try to solve the mysterious death of Alan Hargrove. Alan, the younger brother of Liam Hargrove, the CEO of Hargrove Industries, was found dead under suspicious circumstances. The grand dining hall is decorated in the opulent style befitting the Hargrove family’s status. A large table dominates the room, set for a formal dinner. Portraits of the Hargrove ancestors adorn the walls, watching over the events with an air of solemn dignity. The air is thick with tension and unspoken accusations as you gather to solve the mystery.
[Get Script]

⌛ Deadly Countdown (5-6 Players) [2024] ~2h

Imagine entering an escape room with friends, only to discover a real bomb set to explode in 90 minutes. With time running out, you must accomplish three crucial tasks: defuse the bomb, escape the room, and uncover who planted it—because not everyone might be following the same aim. Can you figure out the saboteur’s identity before time runs out?
Mark your calendars for December 31st

🎨 The Collector’s Last Bid (6-7 Players) [2024] ~3-4h

At the Deceptive Art Gala, a wealthy collector is found dead just moments after the dramatic reveal of a long-lost masterpiece, now ready to be sold to the highest bidder. As rival collectors, artists, and dealers scramble for control of the masterpiece, dark secrets come to light, and everyone becomes a suspect. Who killed Vincent Evans, and what are they willing to do to possess the ultimate treasure?
[Get Script]

🏝 Treasure at Skull Island (6-11 Players) [2024] ~3-4h

The British Crown has summoned a meeting at The Salty Parrot in Port Royal to negotiate a non-attack pact with local pirates in exchange for intelligence and support against the growing Spanish threat in the Caribbean. Tension fills the tavern as Pirate Captain Blackbeard is found dead just minutes before the meeting. His sudden death casts uncertainty over the negotiations, and time is running out. Accusations fly, hidden agendas surface, and the truth behind Blackbeard’s death must be uncovered to restore peace before it’s too late.
Mark your calendars for December 29th

Overview of My Murder Mystery Games in Progress

⛪ Whispers in the Cloister (5-6 Players) [2025]

The peaceful St. Benedict’s Monastery, nestled high in the mountains is thrown into chaos when a chilling scream echoes through the hall. The monks and nuns, gathered for their evening meal, are shaken to find Father Ambrose dead in the library, a cryptic message written in ancient script beside him. The residents find themselves questioning loyalty, faith, and betrayal as the monastery’s dark secrets begin to surface. With its mystical atmosphere — flickering candlelight, ancient stone walls, and the faint sound of chanting — no one is safe within the cloister.
Coming soon, planned for autumn 2025

🔥 Smouldering Secrets (6-7 Players) [2025]

The annual Summer Barbecue at the opulent lakeside estate of the Blackwood family has always been the social event of the season. This year, the party is more lavish than ever, with lanterns lighting the trees, a jazz band playing soft tunes, and the scent of grilled delicacies wafting through the air. The night promises delicious food, fine wine, and engaging company — until it all goes up in smoke with a shocking murder.
Coming soon, planned for summer 2025

🎭 The Midnight Masquerade (9-11 Players) [2025]

In the grand ballroom of the prestigious Blackwood Estate, an annual masquerade ball is underway. Baron Maximillian Blackwood, has invited his closest friends and business partners to his estate, claiming to have a big announcement about his latest plans and the family fortune. As the evening unfolds, the guests mingle, each hiding secrets behind their masks. However, as the clock strikes midnight, a piercing scream echoes through the estate. The guests rush to the library, where they find the Baron dead, slumped over his desk, a spilled glass of wine beside him.
Coming soon, planned for winter 2025

Please Share Your Feedback!

I’d love to hear your thoughts on the murder mystery games! If you have any constructive suggestions or feedback, please feel free to send them to benjimurdermystery@gmail.com. Your insights help me improve the games and ensure that every mystery is a thrilling experience for your group!

If you’ve had fun playing any of my murder mysteries, I’d be honored if you’d consider making a small donation to a charity that’s meaningful to you. Your generosity can make a real difference, and it’s a wonderful way to pay it forward.

Copyright & Usage Terms

Please note that all of my murder mystery games are free to play for private use only. They may not be used for commercial events or distributed elsewhere without explicit permission.